SHANAZ, 1 EDWARD STREET

A nicely appointed restaurant in contemporary style with pale wooden floors, pastel green colouring and good quality cutlery and linen. It seats about 70 in total. Greatly different from its much smaller and cramped accommodation down a side alley off River Street from where it moved in 2000, although the ownership, management and chef have remained the same (according to the head waiter at the time - " it's all the same apart from the chairs").

I first visited 1999 at the previous address and wasn't particularly impressed, and visited the new premises in 2003 when once again I felt the food had not improved to the extent of the premises. On that occasion I found the Onion Bhajias to be stodgy, the main dishes disappointing and the Peshwari Nan lacking in any filling other than a faint smear of almond paste. I am afraid this resulted in a less than encouraging report and a disinclination to return. However, a contact in Truro - who frequently visits many Indian restaurants in the area - informed me that the bhajias had improved, and that in his experience the food is usually good, although the chef travels home to Bangla Desh periodically. It seemed possible that I had suffered an unfortunate and untypical experience, so it was time to revisit and put it to the test.

Well, I'm very glad I did, as the whole meal was excellent (and I was incognito, so no special treatment). The Onion Bhajias had certainly improved since my previous visit, being crisp, tasty and lacking the previous stodge. The Chicken Chat was excellent, being a little different from average as it had more a sweet than sharp taste, and was quite different in flavour and cooking from last time. I found it delicious.

For the main dishes we chose Chicken Jalfrezi and a Tandoori Chicken. The Jalfrezi was first class - hot, tasty and with sliced chillis properly cooked into the dish to give it the hot, underlying flavour (which is how it should be, and not with fresh chillis just sprinkled on top, which is often done and a practice which detracts from the taste). The Tandoori Chicken was also excellent, being well marinated and substantial, meaty pieces of chicken. Dall Shamber was very tasty with plenty of spinach, and the accompanying rice and Peshwari Nan a good average, although the Nan was again a vast improvement on before as it did have some filling this time. 

The service was good (apart from the table reservation - see below)) and the portions quite sufficient. At the time of my first visit the prices were the cheapest of the four restaurants in Truro but inevitably they have risen, as should be expected, with the standard of the accommodation. However, no restaurant in Truro is cheap compare with national averages, and by Truro standards a random basket price check shows the Shanaz to be very competitively priced and good value.

The only thing that I would still take issue with is the table reservation system. On the last occasion I reported that - " when we arrived I had doubts about their booking system as I had booked a table in the non-smoking, but when we arrived the waiter didn't give the appearance we were expected or had a table booked, but looked worriedly into the non-smoking room as if to see whether there were any spaces. Fortunately there was a table (not set up) and this was quickly laid, but personally I think we were just lucky". On this occasion I had similarly booked - a couple of days in advance to give adequate notice - but when we arrived I could see that all tables in the non-smoking area were full. We were asked to sit in the reception area, where the waiter kept saying "two minutes" every three or four minutes. It was fifteen minutes before the occupants of a table started to move and we were eventually accommodated, so I still feel that the booking system could do with some improvement (or abolish it if its not going to function properly). However, this is perhaps a small gripe compared with the vast improvements I found in the meal. I don't know what happened on my previous visit (I can only assume the normal chef was away and I visited when a locum was in the kitchen), but I am delighted to record that on this occasion we enjoyed a first class meal, and unlike before I am pleased to say that I will be happy to return. In fact, I'm even looking forward to it. 

As an aside, it's also worth mentioning that I'm told they also do a lot of good work for charity.

Malcolm Wilkins - September 2004